Are Our Windows Making Us Sick?

Are Our Windows Making Us Sick?

Rethinking Glass, Sunlight, and Human Health in Modern Buildings with Joe Menchefski

Rethinking Glass, Sunlight, and Human Health in Modern Buildings with Joe Menchefski

Teilen:

window glass deflects beneficial sunlight from humans living indoors in modern buildings

We spend up to 95% of our lives indoors.

Inside homes. Inside offices. Inside schools. Inside warehouses built from steel and glass. And while modern architecture has become more energy efficient than ever before, a deeper question is beginning to surface:

In optimizing buildings for energy, have we unintentionally de-optimized them for human biology?

A recent conversation with daylighting expert and chemical engineer Joe Menchefski shines a light—literally—on a growing issue in building design: the spectral quality of light that enters our buildings.

The Invisible Trade-Off in Modern Glass

Over the last few decades, building design has rightly focused on energy performance. Since the 1970s energy crisis, architects and engineers have worked tirelessly to reduce heat loss, improve insulation, and minimize energy waste.

One major innovation has been low-emissivity (low-E) glass.

Low-E coatings improve thermal performance by blocking parts of the infrared (IR) and ultraviolet (UV) spectrum. The result? Better insulation in winter, less heat gain in summer, and improved overall energy efficiency.

But here’s the emerging concern:

In filtering out specific wavelengths to improve energy performance, we may also be filtering out wavelengths essential to human health.

indoor living causes myopia children need sunlight for eye development and calibration

The Myopia Epidemic and “Eye Calibration”

One of the most striking examples comes from research into childhood myopia (nearsightedness).

Rates of myopia are rising dramatically worldwide. While screen use is often blamed, emerging research suggests something deeper may be at play: insufficient exposure to full-spectrum natural light.

During early childhood, the eye undergoes a kind of “calibration” process. Certain wavelengths of sunlight — particularly around the violet/near-UV range (~380nm) — appear to play a role in regulating eye development and shape.

If that spectral input is missing or reduced, the eye may not develop its optimal geometry, potentially contributing to nearsightedness.

Modern low-E glass often cuts off light near this range.

The science is still evolving and not yet fully settled — but the implications are profound. Children today spend the vast majority of their time indoors, behind glass, under artificial lighting.

We may be redesigning their light environment without fully understanding the biological consequences.

LED Lighting: Efficient but Incomplete

The issue doesn’t stop at windows.

LED lighting has revolutionized energy efficiency. But LEDs do not emit a full-spectrum light comparable to the sun.

Many LED systems:

  • Reduce red and infrared wavelengths

  • Emphasize certain blue peaks

  • Lack the natural spectral progression that occurs from sunrise to sunset

Why does this matter?

Because light does more than allow us to see.

Our bodies use specific wavelengths to regulate:

  • Circadian rhythms

  • Sleep cycles

  • Hormone production

  • Mitochondrial function

  • Metabolism

Blue wavelengths (~480nm) help signal daytime alertness.
Red and infrared wavelengths are associated with evening regulation and cellular function.

When we live in buildings that block full-spectrum sunlight and rely on partial-spectrum artificial lighting, we may be disrupting deeply embedded biological processes.

The Energy vs. Human Health Paradox

From a purely mathematical perspective, the most energy-efficient building would have no windows at all.

Fully insulated walls. No thermal transfer. LED lighting inside.

But that building would almost certainly produce lower productivity, reduced wellbeing, and potentially long-term health consequences for its occupants.

This is the central paradox facing modern architecture:

Energy efficiency alone is not a complete design strategy.

Buildings are not thermodynamic machines.
They are habitats for biological organisms evolved under the sun.

Emerging Solutions

The good news? The industry is beginning to adapt.

vacuum insulated glass improved insulation enables more transparency and better indoor lighting

1. Vacuum Insulated Glass (VIG)

Vacuum insulated glass removes air between panes to dramatically improve insulation without requiring thick, heavy multi-pane systems.

It allows:

  • High transparency

  • Strong thermal performance

  • Potential retention of broader spectral transmission

This could reduce the need for aggressive spectral filtering in low-E coatings.

2. Diffused Daylighting

Direct sunlight causes glare and thermal discomfort. Historically, designers avoided it.

But direct sunlight is also what enables deep light penetration into large spaces.

Modern diffused daylighting systems soften sunlight while preserving its spectral quality — delivering high-quality illumination without glare.

Shadowmap enables easy 3D planning of smarter building orientation and passive design windows energy efficiency

3. Smarter Orientation and Passive Design

Sometimes the most powerful solution is not a new material — but better design.

Rotating a building by even 20–30 degrees can significantly reduce heating and cooling loads while improving daylight access.

Optimizing:

  • Window placement

  • Building orientation

  • Overhangs and shading

  • Solar exposure timing

… can reduce energy consumption and improve human light exposure simultaneously.

This is not a zero-sum game.

It is an optimization problem.

A Cultural Shift Is Beginning

Architects are increasingly aware of this balancing act.

Researchers are quantifying the value of views, daylight quality, and spectral composition. Health-optimized buildings are becoming part of mainstream discussion.

But widespread change requires more than innovation. It requires awareness.

Most people don’t realize:

  • Glass filters light.

  • LED light is not equivalent to sunlight.

  • Invisible wavelengths influence sleep, metabolism, and development.

Once that awareness spreads, demand for better solutions will follow.

spending time outdoors in daylight under the sun is helping children prevent myopia

Small Steps, Big Impact

While industry adapts, individuals can act now:

  • Spend more time outdoors, especially children.

  • Seek morning sunlight exposure.

  • Allow natural daylight into homes when possible.

  • Use warmer lighting in the evening.

  • Pay attention to orientation when buying or designing a home.

Sometimes improving your relationship with the sun is as simple as opening a window at the right time of day.

Designing for Biology

For millions of years, human physiology evolved under full-spectrum sunlight.

In less than a century, we have radically altered that light environment.

Energy efficiency remains essential — but it must be balanced with biology.

The future of building design will not be about choosing between sustainability and health.

It will be about integrating both.

Because ultimately, buildings are not for energy models.

They are for humans.

Diesen Artikel teilen:

City of Vienna with interactive sunlight simulation

Finde jetzt ein sonnigen Ort.
In Echtzeit. Weltweit.

City of Vienna with interactive sunlight simulation

Finde jetzt ein sonnigen Ort.
In Echtzeit. Weltweit.

City of Vienna with interactive sunlight simulation

Finde jetzt ein sonnigen Ort.
In Echtzeit. Weltweit.

Hol dir deine Dosis ☀️ Nachrichten.

Hol dir deine Dosis ☀️ Nachrichten.

Hol dir deine Dosis ☀️ Nachrichten.

Download the Shadowmap App

Solarkompetenz auf Knopfdruck

Die weltweit erste interaktive App für globale Interaktive 3D Sonnenlicht-Simulation. Visualisiere Licht für jeden Ort, jede Zeit und jedes Datum. Perfekt für Solarenergie, Immobilien, Architektur, Fotografie und mehr!

Download the Shadowmap App

Solarkompetenz auf Knopfdruck

Die weltweit erste interaktive App für globale Interaktive 3D Sonnenlicht-Simulation. Visualisiere Licht für jeden Ort, jede Zeit und jedes Datum. Perfekt für Solarenergie, Immobilien, Architektur, Fotografie und mehr!